Short answer
For technical rock climbing, El Capitan is generally considered harder. For hiking, Half Dome is usually the tougher day for most visitors. Which peak is “harder” depends on whether you mean climbing or hiking.
Technical climbing: El Capitan
El Capitan is a granite wall roughly 3,000 feet high. Its best-known routes, including The Nose and Freerider, are long and committing, and many take several days. The hardest free routes on El Capitan are among the most difficult in Yosemite. Big-wall climbing also requires skills in hauling gear, managing ropes and planning multi-day logistics.
Technical climbing: Half Dome
Half Dome’s easiest technical route is Snake Dike, rated 5.7 R. It’s moderate in difficulty, but its protection is sparse in places. Half Dome also has much harder free routes, though they are less commonly climbed and have long approaches.
Hiking: Half Dome
The cable hike is about 14 to 16 miles round trip from Happy Isles, with roughly 4,800 feet of elevation gain. It ends with about 400 feet of steep granite and cables, and you need a permit when the cables are up. Many visitors consider it the more demanding day, though opinions vary.
Hiking: El Capitan
Most visitors don’t hike to the top of El Capitan. The trails in the area are steep too, and people disagree about which is more taxing: the steep trails near El Capitan, or the full Half Dome hike with its cables.
So which is harder?
- If you’re climbing, El Capitan’s big-wall routes are generally the harder technical undertaking, and they’re not a first objective.
- If you’re hiking, Half Dome’s cable route is usually the harder day.
- If you’re a fit hiker without climbing experience, the cable hike is a far more realistic goal than El Capitan.
For the hike details and Snake Dike, see the Half Dome climbing routes guide. For the wider Yosemite picture, see the Yosemite climbing guide.